E-Game Evaluation Rubrics

Game Being Evaluated:

Evaluator:

	Beginning	Developing	Accomplished	Exemplary	Score
Utility	0 The game doesn't seem to fit a well defined need in a realistic context	1 There are several mismatches between the goals, audience, context and approach used.	2 There are one or two mismatches between the goals, audience, context and approach used.	4 The game seems to address a well described, plausible need in a way that the target audience would actually play.
Design Details	0 It's not at all clear what the game will look like or exactly how it would be played.	3 There are many missing details about interface, game rules, and the overall structure of the game.	6 There are a few missing details about interface, game rules, and the overall structure of the game.	9 All aspects of the game design are clearly described and illustrated graphically.
Motivation	0 The game's motivational elements are unclear or unconvincing.	3 There is some uncertainty about the effectiveness or rationale behind the motivational elements chosen.	6 There is a little uncertainty about the effectiveness or rationale behind the motivational elements chosen.	9 The game would motivate its intended audience. The theory based used is well described.
Design Process	0 There is no account of the thought process used in putting the game together.	1 The process used to design the game is sketchily described.	2 The process used to design the game describes only the final result, not enough about the options considered and rejected.	3 The design process is completely and interestingly described, including rationale, dead ends, and minority reports.
COMMENTS					TOTAL /25